2 Column subreport doesn't split evenly on the second page of report

Problem:

I've got a two column subreport that has a lot of data in it.  Where it appears on the first page of my main report it splits the data evenly into two columns.  However, when it overflows on to the second page it renders the two columns of data as one column that runs the length of the second page pushing all the rest of my report to a third page. 

Expectation:

On the second page, split the subreport in half and render it as two columns.